Finding the right herb for a particular spell can be hard, but finding a substitute can be easy. Belladonna can be hard to find but Tobacco is readily available. Please check the chart below for alternative herbs that can be substituted:
ACACIA = Gum Arabic ACACIA GUM = Gum Arabic ACONITE = Tobacco ARABIC GUM = Frankincense, Gum Mastic, Gum Tragacanth (for binding wet ingredients, not for incense) AMMONIA GUM = Asafetida ASAFOETIDA = Tobacco; Valerian BALM OF GILEAD = Rose buds, Gum Mastic BELLIUM , GUM = Copal; Pine resin; Dragons Blood BELLADONNA = Tobacco BENZOIN = Gum Arabic; Gum Mastic CACHANA = Angelica Root CARNATION = Rose petals anointed with a few drops of clove oil CASSIA = Cinnamon CASTOR BEAN = A few drops of Castor Oil CEDAR = Sandalwood CINQUE FOIL = Clover; Trefoil CITRON = Equal parts of Orange Peel & Lemon Peel CLOVE = Mace, Nutmeg CLOVER = Cinquefoil COPAL= Frankincense; Cedar COW BANE= Tobacco CYPRESS= Juniper; Pine needles DEER'S TONGUE= Tonka Bean (not for internal use); Wood ruff; Vanilla
DITTANY OF CRETE = Gum Mastic DRAGONS BLOOD = Equal Parts of Red Sandalwood and Frankincense EUCALYPTUS OIL = Camphor oil; Lavender Oil EUPHORBIUM = Tobacco FRANKINCENSE = Copal; Pine resin GALANGAL = Ginger Root GRAINS OF PARADISE = Black Pepper GUM AMMONIA = Asafetida GUM BELLIUM = Copal; Pine resin; Dragons Blood
HELLEBORE = Tobacco; Nettle HEMLOCK = Tobacco HEMP = Nutmeg; Damiana; Star Anise; Bay HENBANE = Tobacco HYSSOP = Lavender
IVY = Cinquefoil
JASMINE = Rose JUNIPER = Pine LAVENDER = Rose LEMONGRASS = Lemon Peel LEMON PEEL = Lemongrass; LEMON VERBENA = Lemongrass; Lemon peel MACE = Nutmeg MANDRAKE = Tobacco MASTIC GUM = Gum Arabic; Frankincense MINT(any sort) = Sage MISTLETOE = Mint; Sage MUG WORT = Wormwood NEROLI OIL = Orange Oil NIGHTSHADE = Tobacco NUTMEG = Mace; Cinnamon OAK MOSS = Patchouli ORANGE = Tangerine Peel ORANGE FLOWERS = Orange Peel PATCHOULI = Oak moss PEPPERMINT = Spearmint PEPPER WORT = Rue; Grains of Paradise; Black Pepper PINE = Juniper PINE RESIN = Frankincense; Copal RED SANDALWOOD = Sandalwood mixed with a pinch of Dragons Blood ROSE = Yarrow ROSE GERANIUM = Rose RUE = Rosemary mixed with a pinch of black pepper SAFFRON = Orange Peel SANDALWOOD = Cedar SARSAPARILLA = Sassafras SASSAFRAS = Sarsaparilla SPEARMINT = Peppermint SULFUR = Tobacco; Club Moss; Asafetida THYME = Rosemary TOBACCO = Bay TONKA BEAN = Vanilla TREFOIL = Cinquefoil VALERIAN = Asafetida VANILLA = Woodruff; Deers tongue; Tonka Bean VETIVERT = Calamus WOLFSBANE = Tobacco WOOD ALOE = Sandalwood Sprinkled with Ambergris Oil WOODRUFF = Deer's tongue; Vanilla